Applying for a job? Give AI a miss

Job applications need brains, not AI

Experience, education and merit, plays no part in AI resume writing and screening software.

Organisations who sell this software call it ‘disruptive’. I call it dangerous and deluded. I run Republic Resumes and I know candidates or merit are being knocked back due to screening technology.

Senior recruiters across American now say using AI is killing job applicant’s short-listing chances. They get thousands of resumes and application materials that are so similar, because people have used the same prompts to customise their applications.

Job applicants are already facing a wall of chatbots and a battery of machine prompts. AI will decide whether they’re a good match or not. The software doesn’t even tell them how they’ve been evaluated.

Some businesses are on the cusp of using body-language analysis, vocal assessments and gamified tests to hire people. Utter madness.

Sapia, a long-running AI interview platform, has conducted 9 million AI interviews for clients including Qantas, Woolworths, Bunnings and other major employers.

Interviewees are conduct using text chat with an AI agent, which provides details on the company and position, describes how data from the chat will be used, warns against copying or generating text, and asks five questions – such as “describe a time you overcame a challenge” or “where do you see yourself in five years?” – that the interviewee is encouraged to answer using 50 to 100 words with no time limit.

Algorithm-facilitated discrimination is especially problematic because the predictions and outcomes generated from these systems are often difficult to contest and the processes they use tend to be opaque.

This appalling state of affairs demoralising job applicants, hobbling the companies who foolishly installed the AI-driven recruitment platforms, and the killing economic productivity. Employers hire people for their brains, potential and skills.

You’ve written the resume and it’s a killer. You’re perfect for the job. Education. Tick. Training. Tick. Referees. Tick. You’ve even got a short testimonial from the head of HR when you did a workplace for the company you’re applying for. Big Tick.

You send it off and there’s a spring in your step. A week passes. Two weeks pass and you ring up the recruiter. She says, ‘sorry but the AI resume scanner dumped your resume. It didn’t like the testimonial or the format.’

AI resumes scanners are spiking the strongest resumes because they don’t conform to a bizarre pre-set notion of what a resume is. If a resume does not have the appropriate key words, it’s spiked. If it has non-standard formatting or structure, it’s spiked. If it has a couple of graphics, it’s spiked.

While I’ve had serious reservations about the ethics and competency of some recruiters, at least I can call them on the phone. Not so with a resume scanner.

Experience, education and merit, plays no part in the magical symbiosis of big data and resume screening software. Organisations who sell this software call it ‘disruptive’. I call it dangerous and deluded.

Republic Resumes now works with job applicants to rewrite their AI- generated resumes in the active voice and include achievements. We get them past the ridiculous screening functions.

We must jettison AI from the hiring function as it’s a disaster on a monumental scale.

The ‘inevitability narrative’ is being pushed by big tech companies. It’s in their interest to make the case we must all use AI in recruitment otherwise we will get left behind.

The promise is AI scanners will save businesses money by eliminating the human element, i.e. recruiters. So, they’ll take the humans out of the equation from a profession which is all about humans?

AI generates vague achievements like “responsible for managing teams” instead of real metric-driven results such as “led a team of 12 and improved delivery time by 25%.” Resumes with specific and factual numbers and measurable outcomes are far more likely to receive callbacks.

AI lacks the ability to position a candidate’s experience in a compelling narrative that aligns with the employer’s goals. A human writer can frame transferable skills, career progression, and relevance to the target role, something AI can’t do.

AI in recruitment is dangerous and is not only demoralising people who want to work for a specific organisation but it is destroying the human capital component of workplace productivity.

It’s a race to the bottom.

By Malcolm King, Director, Republic Resumes

Put your best foot forward

Malcolm builds expert resumes, cover letters and LinkedIn profiles, which unleash an unbeatable business case to promote you as a ‘must have’ asset to an employer.