Ripping off young people

$45K entry job wants experience + Master’s degree

Some employers are ripping off young people. In this case the employer reeled back quick but only after the story went viral.

A position requiring more than three years of experience and a degree sparked outrage after being shared online.

The ad was originally posted by a Melbourne-based call centre operator, seeking a junior C# developer on a salary of $45,000 to $65,000.

The “100 per cent on-site” position requires a Bachelor’s degree in IT or a related field but “Master’s preferred”, and “three-plus years” experience in software development, “including architecture and team management”.

“Are you obsessed with writing clean and readable code and excited to contribute to programming software that helps customers?” the listing reads.

“Join this dynamic team and play a crucial role in developing B2B management and software applications that are revolutionising the software world.”

The job ad was shared Reddit by a user who asked, “WTF is this job listing?”

“I don’t understand how they can call a candidate with three-plus years’ experience and preferably a Master’s degree ‘entry level’,” they wrote.

“What a joke. Would’ve had at least three to four years in university and three years’ real experience for seven total years of learning/experience to be called entry level and an absolute disgrace of a salary.”

In Australia, the annual minimum wage is just under $48,000, while the Professional Employees Award, which covers IT workers, stipulates a minimum annual salary of $61,638 for a graduate with a three-year degree.

“This is called a red flag company/taking the piss,” one user wrote.

“Ah yes, the entry level developer with three years’ team management experience,” another said.

A third said, “They’ll use this as an excuse to outsource labour offshore or implement AI. They will never find someone who is ‘suitable’ because the listing is a joke, and someone with a Master’s in CS would be a clown to take it.”

Some questioned whether the company was simply completing the required “labour market testing” prior to sponsoring a foreign worker.

“Generally companies just complete the labour market testing as tick the box exercise and will add a two to three years’ work experience requirement to narrow down applications they receive so doesn’t look as bad when they don’t accept any applicants,” one said.

After the negative media a spokesman for OracleCMS said the listed salary was an ‘error’, and the position actually starts at $65,000.

Sure.

Last year a survey found than one in three young people had been ripped off by employers, and most of them did not seek redress, according to a new study from Melbourne Law School.

The survey of 2814 workers under 30 found that:

  • 33% had been paid $15 per hour or less (the current federal minimum wage is $24.95 per hour)
  • 9% had not been paid for all work completed.
  • 5% had been given food or products instead of being paid in money.
  • 8% had been forced to return some or all of their pay to employer.

“Wage exploitation is rife among employers who hire young people,” study lead Professor John Howe said. “Young people don’t have much industrial knowledge or experience, so are easy to take advantage of. They are also unlikely to challenge an employer, as many of them are in insecure work and they worry about losing their jobs.”

His research, part of the Fair Day’s Work project at Melbourne Law School, found that there were many other ways in which employers exploited young staff:

  • 60% had had to pay for work-related items or activities, such as uniforms, protective equipment, training or car fuel.
  • 36% had been forbidden to take entitled breaks.
  • 34% were not paid for work during a trial period.
  • 24% had not been paid compulsory super.

“It was also reported that employers often cooked the books, presumably to avoid fair wage rates and the Tax Office,” Professor Howe said. “Twenty-one percent of the young people said they were sometimes paid off the books, and 12 per cent were always paid off the books. Eight per cent never even received a payslip.”

Put your best foot forward

Malcolm builds expert resumes, cover letters and LinkedIn profiles, which unleash an unbeatable business case to promote you as a ‘must have’ asset to an employer.